How to Set Up Automated Follow-Up Sequences with Keap and Calendly Integration

In today’s fast-paced business environment, manual follow-ups are a bottleneck, consuming valuable time and introducing human error. Automating your post-booking interactions can significantly enhance client engagement, reduce no-shows, and streamline your sales and onboarding processes. This guide provides a clear, step-by-step approach to integrating Keap and Calendly to create a robust, automated follow-up system that works tirelessly for your business, ensuring every lead and client receives timely, personalized communication without a single manual touchpoint.

Step 1: Define Your Integration Objectives and Audience

Before diving into technical configurations, clearly define what you aim to achieve with this integration. Are you looking to nurture leads post-initial consultation, onboard new clients, or ensure timely follow-ups for specific service inquiries? Understanding your objective will dictate the content and timing of your follow-up sequences. Consider your target audience’s journey: what information do they need at each stage? What actions do you want them to take? For a professional services firm like 4Spot Consulting, this might involve sending pre-meeting preparation materials, post-meeting summaries, or links to relevant resources, all tailored to move a prospect further down the funnel or ensure a smooth client experience.

Step 2: Ensure Keap and Calendly Account Readiness

To seamlessly integrate, both your Keap and Calendly accounts must be properly set up and optimized. In Keap, ensure you have the necessary campaigns, tags, and custom fields defined that will support your follow-up logic. This includes creating tags for specific Calendly event types (e.g., “Discovery Call Booked,” “OpsMap™ Scheduled”) and custom fields to store booking details. For Calendly, verify that your event types are correctly configured with appropriate durations, availability, and pre-booking questions. These questions can be crucial for enriching the data that flows into Keap, allowing for highly personalized follow-ups. Consistent data hygiene in both platforms will be key to preventing errors.

Step 3: Connect Keap and Calendly via an Automation Platform

While both platforms offer some native integrations, leveraging a powerful automation platform like Make.com (formerly Integromat) provides unparalleled flexibility and control. This allows for complex conditional logic and multi-step workflows. Set up a scenario in Make.com where a Calendly event trigger (e.g., “Invitee Created”) initiates an action in Keap. This typically involves searching for or creating a contact in Keap, applying specific tags based on the Calendly event type, and then initiating a corresponding Keap campaign. Make.com acts as the intelligent bridge, ensuring data integrity and allowing you to map fields precisely, guaranteeing your Keap campaigns are triggered accurately and with the right context.

Step 4: Design Your Follow-Up Sequences in Keap

With the integration bridge established, focus on crafting robust follow-up campaigns within Keap. These sequences should be logical and progression-based, with clear goals for each step. For a new lead, an initial email might confirm the meeting and provide pre-call materials, followed by a reminder, and then a post-call summary with a clear next step. Use Keap’s campaign builder to create decision diamond logic, allowing you to branch sequences based on contact tags, custom field values, or actions taken (e.g., email opens, link clicks). Incorporate a mix of email, SMS (if appropriate), and even internal task creation for your team members to ensure comprehensive engagement.

Step 5: Configure Calendly Event Types to Trigger Keap Campaigns

Each Calendly event type (e.g., “15-Minute Intro Call,” “60-Minute Strategy Session”) should be designed to trigger a specific, relevant Keap campaign. In your Make.com scenario, map each Calendly event type to the appropriate Keap tag and subsequent campaign. This ensures that when a client books a “Discovery Call,” they immediately enter the “Discovery Call Follow-Up” Keap sequence, distinct from someone booking an “OpsMap™ Diagnostic.” Use Calendly’s custom questions to gather key information during booking that can then be passed to Keap to further personalize the initial email in the follow-up sequence, setting a professional and efficient tone right from the start.

Step 6: Implement and Thoroughly Test the Automation

Once your Keap campaigns are built and your Make.com scenario is configured, it’s critical to conduct extensive testing. Book appointments in Calendly using various event types and monitor the data flow into Keap. Check that the correct contact is created or updated, the appropriate tags are applied, and the designated Keap campaign is initiated precisely as intended. Verify that all emails and SMS messages within the sequence are delivered, correctly formatted, and contain accurate, personalized information. Test all decision points and delays within your Keap campaigns to ensure the logic flows correctly, ensuring a seamless user experience before going live.

Step 7: Monitor, Analyze, and Optimize for Continuous Improvement

Implementing automation is not a set-it-and-forget-it task. Regularly monitor the performance of your Keap-Calendly integration. Track key metrics such as email open rates, click-through rates, conversion rates from follow-up sequences, and overall client engagement. Analyze which parts of your sequences are most effective and identify areas for improvement. Utilize Keap’s reporting features to gain insights into campaign performance. Based on this data, continually refine your email content, adjust timing, and explore new automation possibilities to further enhance efficiency and effectiveness. This iterative process ensures your automated follow-up sequences remain optimized and aligned with your business objectives.

If you would like to read more, we recommend this article: Keap Data Protection: Your Essential Backup & Recovery Playbook

By Published On: December 13, 2025

Ready to Start Automating?

Let’s talk about what’s slowing you down—and how to fix it together.

Share This Story, Choose Your Platform!