How to Set Up Your First Automated Candidate Nurturing Campaign in Keap CRM: A Step-by-Step Guide

In today’s competitive talent landscape, simply posting a job and waiting for applications is no longer enough. Proactive engagement and consistent communication are vital to attracting and retaining top candidates. An automated candidate nurturing campaign in Keap CRM allows recruiting teams to build relationships, keep talent engaged, and ensure a warm pipeline for future roles, all while saving valuable time. This guide will walk you through setting up your first effective campaign, turning passive interest into active applications and reducing your time-to-hire.

Step 1: Define Your Nurturing Goals and Audience Segments

Before building anything in Keap, clarify what you aim to achieve. Are you looking to keep silver medalist candidates warm, re-engage past applicants for new roles, or educate potential future hires about your company culture? Your goals will dictate the campaign’s content and frequency. Simultaneously, segment your audience. Keap’s tagging system is invaluable here. You might have tags like “Silver Medalist – Sales,” “Past Applicant – Marketing,” or “Pipeline Lead – Tech.” Each segment should have a unique set of needs and interests, informing the personalized journey you’re about to create. This foundational step ensures your automation efforts are targeted and impactful, preventing generic messaging that alienates potential talent.

Step 2: Map Out Your Candidate Journey and Touchpoints

With goals and segments defined, visualize the journey. How will a candidate enter this nurturing campaign, and what sequence of communications should they receive? Typically, this involves a series of emails, but it could also include SMS messages, internal tasks for recruiters to follow up, or even personalized video links. Consider the information candidates need at each stage: an initial welcome, company insights, testimonials, career development opportunities, or upcoming job alerts. Outline the timing between each touchpoint – daily, weekly, or bi-weekly. A well-mapped journey ensures a logical flow of information, keeping candidates engaged without overwhelming them, and moving them closer to your desired action, such as applying for a new position.

Step 3: Build Your Nurture Sequence in Keap CRM

Navigate to the “Automation” section in Keap and choose to create a new “Campaign.” This is where you’ll visually construct your journey. Start with a “Sequence” element, which will house the series of emails or actions. Within the sequence, drag and drop “Email” elements for each communication, “Delay” timers to space out messages, and “Task” elements for internal recruiter follow-ups. Label everything clearly so anyone on your team can understand the campaign’s logic. Keap’s intuitive drag-and-drop interface makes it straightforward to arrange these components, ensuring your candidate journey aligns perfectly with the map you created in the previous step.

Step 4: Craft Compelling Content for Each Stage

The success of your nurturing campaign hinges on the quality of your content. For each email or message in your Keap sequence, write engaging, value-driven copy that resonates with your target candidate segment. Focus on providing insights into your company culture, employee success stories, career growth opportunities, and any unique benefits your organization offers. Use personalization fields within Keap (e.g., `~Contact.FirstName~`) to make each message feel tailored. A strong call to action, whether it’s to visit your careers page, connect on LinkedIn, or simply reply to an email with questions, is essential. Remember, the goal is to build a relationship, not just to broadcast.

Step 5: Set Up Automation Triggers and Conditions

Now, connect your Keap campaign to a trigger that automatically enrolls candidates. Common triggers include applying for a specific job (and not being hired), being tagged as a “Silver Medalist” during an interview process, or opting in via a landing page form for job alerts. In Keap, you’ll use a “Goal” element to define these entry points. For example, a “Tag Applied” goal can start the campaign when a recruiter applies a specific tag to a contact record. Additionally, consider exit conditions: what action should remove a candidate from the nurturing campaign? This could be “Job Application Submitted” or “Tag Removed – Not Interested.” Proper triggering and exit conditions ensure candidates receive relevant messages at the right time and avoid sending redundant communications.

Step 6: Test, Analyze, and Optimize Your Campaign

Before setting your campaign live, thoroughly test every step. Enroll a test contact, ensure all emails are sent correctly, personalization fields populate, and delays function as expected. Once live, continuously monitor its performance. Keap provides analytics on email open rates, click-through rates, and goal conversions. Pay attention to which messages resonate most and which lead to desired actions. Use A/B testing for subject lines or content to identify improvements. Recruit feedback from candidates where appropriate. An automated nurturing campaign isn’t a “set it and forget it” solution; it’s an iterative process. Regular analysis and optimization are key to maximizing its effectiveness and ensuring a consistently strong talent pipeline.

If you would like to read more, we recommend this article: The Automated Recruiter’s Guide to Keap CRM: AI-Powered Talent Acquisition

By Published On: January 1, 2026

Ready to Start Automating?

Let’s talk about what’s slowing you down—and how to fix it together.

Share This Story, Choose Your Platform!